Presidents:
- Nina Emery, 2023–present
- Natalja Deng, 2020–2023
- Craig Callender, 2017–2020
- Adrian Bardon, 2014–2017
- Jonathan Tallant, 2011–2014
- Nathan Oaklander, 2006–2010
- William Lane Craig, 2000–2006
- Nathan Oaklander, 1997–2000
- Jon Torgerson, 1993–1996
Vice-presidents:
- David Ingram, 2023–present
- Maria Balcells, 2017–2023
- Ulrich Meyer, 2012–2017
- Jonathan Tallant, 2008–2011
- Adrian Bardon, 2007–2009
Secretaries:
- Marta Pedroni, 2023–present
- Cristian Mariani, 2020–2023
- Natalja Deng, 2017–2020
- Kristie Miller, up to 2017
Treasurers (position no longer active):
- Anncy Thresher, 2017–2020
- Tim Schoettle